Be the change

Categories: Discussion

I hear a lot of people talking about change. About how white people need to acknowledge their privilege. How straight people need to acknowledge their presumption/prejudice. How males need to be conscious of their dominance. These are all insightful and true. We do live in a patriarchal eurocentric society.  The monoculture of which we all partake conditions us to perceive non-heterosexual orientation as un-normal, an aberration, or at best, a quirky character on a hit sitcom. This same monoculture teaches us that black people and white people are “different”.  So much so that it is a comic device to show a white person rapping or a black person being a nerd.
We should all be conscious of  our identity and how this informs our perception. We should not jump to any conclusions when we deal with each other. Do not assume a white person has an issue with you because of the melanin in your skin. Do not assume a black person has an issue with your whiteness either.

Over all these are issue that we need to work on as individuals. You cannot beat the racism out of the racist.  They need to be educated and above all be open to be educated.  Of course the same goes for homophobia and misogyny.  Badgering someone into not saying “bitch” or “fag” will not change their underlying beliefs about sexual preference or gender. There is no set of procedures that can defeat prejudice. Though many have tried.
For example, auditions for the SF Symphony are held in Davies symphony hall. They construct a tunnel out of black cloth running from stage left to center stage. In the middle of the stage is an 8 foot by 8 foot square of 7 foot high black curtains. The floor is covered with sound deadening matts. This is to ensure that the judges can not see the race, age or gender of the candidates. They also can not hear their footfalls to judge their gender or size by the kind of sound they make.  All to ensure they are only judged on the music they perform.
Of course we do not have such resources. Instead we need to do this ourselves in an internal  fashion. Don’t assume someone says anything because of who you perceive them to be. Just evaluate their statements on their own merits. Not as a black mans words or a white womans words, just as an Oaklanders words.

By an accident of history, in English, words do not have gender the way they do in German or French or Spanish or other European languages. This is not a bad thing. Neither do words have race or sexual orientation.  Judge people by their words and actions not your prejudice.

Finally if you are in this to free black people from their oppression, or to free women from their oppression,  or queer people from their oppression, you will lose.  You will run out of steam. You will only have so much energy to devote to selfless activism before you hit bottom. And at the end of the day there will still be queers, women and black people who are oppressed, coerced and imprisoned both literally and metaphorically.  In the long run they will not be free until they make themselves free. And they are not asking for the straight white men and women of the world to rescue them.
If however you are in this to free yourself from oppression you will never run out of steam. That is selfishness in the best possible way.  As soon as you are ready to be free, you are. You do not need acknowledgment of an outside authority to free yourself.

13081

3 Responses to “Be the change”

  1. calaverasgrandes

    I didnt even graduate high school, and I only have a few junior college courses, no diploma. Nothing. I have educated myself with public libraries. You learn so much more when you can inhabit another persons mind due to their talent and ferlessness at writing. Kurt Vonnegut for example I found to be very insightful when I was homeless and bewildered. I learned much more about life from his books than I did in my 3 years of high school.
    But more sincerely, I dont appreciate your arbitrarily divisive railing against the middle class. We should all be able to aspire to a middle class lifestyle, if the Trumps and the Buffets of the world werent quite so greedy. Why shouldn’t people own their residence? Why shouldn’t they be able to retire at 55 or 60 while they still have some life left!? This idea that you have to be destitute and suffering before you are “authentic”. This is the romanticized revolution of college students who feel guilty because their backpack cost $200 of their parents money. I say get over it. You didnt choose to be born to those parents. And you cant spite a parent for indulging their offspring.

  2. John Ellis

    How about the 51% most educated and wealthy, the voting majority with all the wealth, how about they be conscious of their dominance over my slow and careful thinking laboring-class.

    NEW LAW
    No one shall discriminate against the uneducated laboring-class, the 49% with no education beyond some high school, those with superior wisdom born of slow and careful thought. For they shall be paid the same wages as those of the 40% educated middle-class.

  3. a_small_voice

    ” In the long run they will not be free until they make themselves free. And they are not asking for the straight white men and women of the world to rescue them.”

    HERE HERE!!!

    ” Just evaluate their statements on their own merits. Not as a black mans words or a white womans words, just as an Oaklanders words.”

    ASHE