Rally in advance of hearing: 8:30 AM. Wear Blue! RSVP here.
BAAQMD Board of Directors Hearing: 9 AM – 5 PM
And online—see this page for link
The danger of burning fossil fuels in our own homes is no joke. Our everyday, domestic gas-powered building appliances actually cause hundreds of deaths each year in the Bay Area, with total health impacts of $890 million. They also account for a quarter of our regional carbon emissions. By exercising its legal authority to regulate NOx—the collective emission of carbon monoxide and nitrogen oxides—which these appliances produce, the Bay Area Air Quality Management District (BAAQMD) wants to further its mission to save lives and clean Bay Area air.
Please join us on March 15 in advocating for a zero-NOx appliance standard!
Following the many Bay Area cities that have voted to ban gas in new buildings, along with recent revelations about how fossil gas harms the climate and human health, BAAQMD is proposing new, trailblazing rulemaking that would ban the sale of new gas furnaces and water heaters within about eight years. Read the laudatory LA Times editorial about this—”Bay Area making climate change history by phasing out sales of gas furnaces and water heaters”—here.
While this rule would have great benefits for the climate and health, it’s also controversial. Large numbers of opponents are expected to be bused in to the all-day hearing on March 15.
For this reason, supporters are strongly urged to give in-person commentary at the hearing, if possible. You can also send in comments in advance to your Air District representative. (Find your rep on the Board of Directors here. Look for your city and county.)
The hazards of fossil gas have been getting a lot of publicity after the December 2022 release of a study reporting that almost 13 percent of childhood asthma is attributable to gas stoves. Burning natural gas causes the release of health-harming nitrogen oxides and particulate matter. And fossil gas equipment—from the well to where it’s burned—inevitably leaks methane, a greenhouse gas with 80 times the climate impact of carbon dioxide in the first 20 years after it’s released.
The proposed Air District rule would not ban gas stoves but would ban most new gas water heaters (in new construction and replacements in homes) after 2027, gas furnaces after 2029, and large gas water heaters (in apartments and commercial buildings) after 2031.
Opponents charge it would put a big financial burden on many households that could not afford it. However, a report prepared for the Air District Board meeting on February 15 outlines the state and federal funding “available for retrofitting low-income homes with cleaner appliances,” and staff have intentionally built in a long lead time of four to eight years for each of the rule components. Implementation will be conditional. Two years prior to compliance dates staff will report on market readiness and equity considerations, and adjust accordingly. And during the rulemaking process, there were be multiple opportunities for public engagement.
To learn more and for help with preparing comments:
Here’s a sample comment from 350 Bay Area:
Dear __________,
As your constituent, I urge you to support our Air District’s proposed changes to rules 9-4 and 9-6 requiring only zero NOx water heaters, furnaces, and large commercial water heaters be sold and installed by 2027, 2029, 2031 respectively, as well as the introduction of an ultra-low NOx standard to Rule 9-4 for furnaces starting in 2024. We urgently need these rule changes to improve air quality and public health in the near term, and to mitigate the impacts of climate change over the long run.
The risk raised in the EIR regarding potentially insufficient grid capacity (to support a transition to electric water heaters and furnaces) can be mitigated by the adoption of increasingly efficient electric appliances, incentives to increase residential battery storage, and other policy measures that will be necessary, regardless of these rules changes, if we are to meet our municipal, regional and state electrification targets and reach zero net GHG emissions by 2040, if not earlier.
The risk of increased noise associated with some electric alternatives is already being addressed with the introduction of new technologies and products that generate far less noise than their older counterparts. This transition can be accelerated via carefully crafted regulations and incentives designed to favor noise reduction in electric appliances.
These two concerns should not be allowed to outweigh the considerably greater risks to public health and the planet from natural gas-powered equipment.
I urge the BAAQMD Board to certify the EIR and adopt these proposed rule changes as quickly as possible.
Thank you,
[Your name, city, and zip]
74709